The holy trinity of circular reason













Also works as a computer program loop:

10 The bible is the word of god
20 What the bible says is true
30 If the bible says it is the word of god then Goto 10

This circular logic is what stumps me every time someone on the radio or in person quotes the bible. Why quote the bible to someone who may not believe in it? Quoting the bible is like quoting your uncle. "As my uncle once said: two plus two equals five." Wow! If your uncle said it, let me take it seriously. Wait, who's your uncle ...?

Flags are too vague for communication.

For many the national flag is a powerful and unambiguous symbol. Unfortunately, it represents a different set of ideas for just about everyone; its exact meaning is never clearly defined. Does it symbolize only the good aspects of a country, or only the negative, or all aspects? Does the flag represent the country as a whole or only its government? Is it a reference to the past, present, or future? Does it represent those who have fought for it? If so, they would have fought for a representation of themselves — a very circular activity.

When you involve the flag in speech you are using an extremely vague pronoun. Imagine using the word "it" with extreme passion. No one would know exactly what you mean, unless they happen to project as you do. What's clear is only that you are passionate, and clueless about your vagueness.
When patriots employ this symbol they are thinking of specifics, but aren't elaborating on specifics in the larger world context. When people burn the flag, they usually have very specific current events in mind, but the ritual is misinterpreted by the patriots as a disaproval of their own personal and perfectly noble ideals. And the patriotic use, on the other hand is misinterpreted by victims and critics of the flag's nation as approval of the clearly reprehensible. Hence the misunderstanding: "they hate our freedom".
Flags are just a terrrible way to communicate. They were invented for battling armies to identify themselves and to indicate the direction of the wind, so that weapons could be hurled with the proper force and angle. They serve to unify different interests against a conceived external entity.
Flags work well for aggression, but terribly for discourse.

Patriotic display is a form of bragging that is tolerated because it compliments the group.

Switzerland is a clock.

This could be meant as a reference to Harry Lime in The Third Man: "In Switzerland they had brotherly love - they had 500 years of democracy and peace, and what did that produce? The cuckoo clock."

Switzerland doesn't just produce clocks and watches, it functions like them.

The Netherlands repeat a picture of tall people on big bikes in front of small houses made of tiny bricks and gigantic windows.




Be it as it may, for, as it were, so be it.